The incident, for people unfamiliar with Sherman’s back story as a star student-athlete at Stanford, turned one of the game’s smartest players into the symbol of what was wrong with the N.F.L. Andrews’s befuddled reaction certainly did not help as she tried to rescue an interview that had gone off the rails.
Credit Chang W. Lee/The New York Times
Four years later, Sherman appears to be in his final days on the Seahawks’ roster, and the team’s famed Legion of Boom defense appears to be fading into something far less spectacular. With Seattle’s secondary hampered by injuries recently, and with the often-dominant lineman Michael Bennett headed to Philadelphia in a trade, this week has the distinct feeling of a page turning on one of the sport’s great defensive units.
But even through those years of on-field dominance, it is telling that Sherman’s interview with Andrews, for some, largely shaped a perception of the player that undersold his influence both on and off the field — and that ignored the historical significance of the team’s defense.
“They misunderstand his passion for the game,” said Kam Chancellor, the team’s hard-hitting safety, in the week leading up to Seattle’s victory over Denver. “He made a great play at the end of the game and he had a microphone in his face. Anything could come out right then.”
For his part, Sherman, a communications major at Stanford, did not appear to be ready to apologize for anything he said — he was fired up, but he did not swear or physically threaten anyone during the interview. In the aftermath, however, he did seem disappointed that there was not enough focus on just how spectacular and meaningful the play had been.
“I think in some people’s eyes, the comments overshadow the play because that’s what they were focusing on,” Sherman said, “but some people actually focused on the game, and they noticed the play and understood what kind of play it was.”
If Earl Thomas was the quiet leader of the Legion of the Boom secondary, and Chancellor was, well, the boom, then Sherman was the group’s spokesman. It was Sherman who taunted Patriots quarterback Tom Brady after a regular-season victory in 2012. It was Sherman who exploded at Crabtree. It was Sherman who held court with the news media week after week.
And yet despite the spotlight squarely trained on him, the fact that he has been one of the top three cornerbacks in the N.F.L. for a significant stretch is sometimes lost in the shuffle.
Credit Dilip Vishwanat/Getty Images
After seven fantastic professional seasons, Sherman is 30 and working to recover from a tear of his Achilles’ tendon that he sustained last season. More important, he is scheduled to count for $13.2 million on the team’s salary cap. If the Seahawks trade or release him by June 1, they will reduce that figure by $11 million. It is entirely possible that he has more good football to play, but there have been widespread reports — and thinly veiled indications from teammates’ tweets — that he will have to do it somewhere other than Seattle.
Sherman’s likely departure, Bennett’s trade to the Eagles, Chancellor’s continuing recovery from a serious neck injury and Thomas’s having missed seven games over the last two seasons because of injury adds up to a drastic overhaul for a defense that will hold a distinct spot in league history.
The unit’s on-field legacy, which includes helping the team to two Super Bowl berths, will most likely be its consistent and enduring dominance. Last year ended a streak of five seasons in which it was ranked in the N.F.L.’s top five in both yardage and scoring defense. Most impressive, Seattle allowed the fewest points in the N.F.L. for four consecutive seasons, 2012 to 2015. It finished third in 2016, leaving it one year short of matching the 1950s Cleveland Browns, who set a record by leading the N.F.L. in that category for five consecutive years.
For comparison, the 2000 Baltimore Ravens were the stingiest single-season defense of any team in the era of the 16-game season, but it took them another six seasons to lead the league again despite the continued presence of stars like Ray Lewis and Ed Reed. Even the Chicago Bears of the mid-1980s, considered the benchmark by many for modern defenses, topped out at leading the N.F.L. in scoring defense in three of four seasons with a fourth-place finish in 1987 ruining their streak.
Should Sherman truly be gone, the Seahawks will still probably field an above-average defense. Thomas and Chancellor will serve as elder statesmen, while Bobby Wagner will still give the team a legitimate superstar on that side of the ball. But with the Los Angeles Rams and the 49ers both ascending, the changing of the guard in the Seattle defense feels like a fantastic story reaching its conclusion, even if quarterback Russell Wilson and his offense can keep the team on the fringes of contention.
Summing up the team’s legacy can be hard, but in 2015, as the Seahawks faced the news media in the lead-up to a heartbreaking loss in Super Bowl XLIX, Thomas was asked to describe the Legion of Boom and explain why the group played so well together, and his words painted the picture far better than any sour memories of Sherman’s rant.
“We flow together,” he said. “It’s a beautiful thing to see, especially when we really recognize what’s going on — the little details. Everybody’s minds are not regular football minds.”