Still, despite the heroics of Bird and Tanaka, who shut out the Indians on three hits over seven innings, and an effective inning from Aroldis Chapman, who retired Carlos Santana on a fly ball to center with two runners on to end the game, the Yankees needed every bit of the 6-foot-7-inch frame of right fielder Aaron Judge to emerge victorious.
Judge has been all but absent at the plate in this series — he is now 0 for 10 with eight strikeouts — but he did his part with his glove when Francisco Lindor, whose grand slam launched the Indians’ comeback in Game 2, lifted a towering fly ball to right field in the sixth inning.
The vibrant ballpark grew silent as the ball carried through the unseasonably warm October air. But Judge, his back as close to the wall as the Yankees’ were on Sunday night, leapt and snatched the ball as it was about to become a two-run homer.
The crowd erupted in cheers and the game remained scoreless. Enter Bird, the 24-year-old whose two homers are the only runs the Yankees have scored in this series against Indians pitchers not named Corey Kluber.
Among those most grateful for the fact there will now be a Game 4 was Yankees Manager Joe Girardi, who had been subjected to withering criticism over his decision not to have a hit-by-pitch call reviewed by the umpires in Game 2, which left the door open for the Indians’ rally.
Girardi acknowledged before Game 3 that “there’s a lot of people upset” with him. That was evident when he was roundly booed when he took the field during pregame introductions.
Credit Ben Solomon for The New York Times
Girardi, whose contract will expire after this season, also told reporters before the game that while he loved managing — and was excited about the possibilities presented by the talented young team the Yankees have built — he would speak with his family before deciding whether he would return next season.
As for whether the Yankees actually want him back, Girardi responded in straightforward fashion.
“That’s Hal’s and Brian’s decision and whatever their decision is, I’ll live with it,” he said, referring to Hal Steinbrenner, the principal owner, and Brian Cashman, the general manager whose contract also expires after this season.
Girardi was set up for more second-guessing on Sunday with his decision to start Tanaka. Though Luis Severino had an abysmal start in the wild-card victory over the Minnesota Twins last week, lasting just one-third of an inning, he had clearly been the Yankees’ best pitcher this season. Meanwhile, Tanaka, while he struck out a career-high 15 batters in his last start of the regular season, had been erratic all year. He allowed a career-high 35 home runs, the fourth-most by a starting pitcher in the majors this season.
And by holding Severino back for Game 4, Girardi risked being eliminated in this series without using his best starter.
“You can say that,” Girardi acknowledged before the game. Then he countered with his own view: If the Yankees were to come back and win the series, they would need Severino at some point.
Whatever the rationale, Tanaka rewarded Girardi’s faith with a brilliant performance, using his fastball and slider to set up a devastating split-fingered fastball, which he leaned on heavily.
The one bit of trouble Tanaka endured came in the fourth when Jason Kipnis scorched a liner to right that carried over the head of Judge, who misjudged the ball and had it deflect off his glove. By the time Judge retrieved the ball and returned it to the infield, Kipnis had slid into the third with a triple.
But Tanaka steeled himself and struck out Jose Ramirez and Jay Bruce — both on splitters in the dirt — to escape.
Tanaka found himself with a runner on base in two other instances — when Carlos Santana singled in the second and walked in the fifth — but he extricated himself with double-play grounders that were turned with ease.
As good as Tanaka was, he needed to be.
Carrasco held the Yankees without a hit until Didi Gregorius singled with two out in the fourth and shut them out into the sixth — just like he did against the Yankees in Cleveland this August. But this time, rather than leave a tiring Carrasco in when the Yankees loaded the bases in the sixth, Indians Manager Terry Francona turned to Miller.
Miller, whom the Yankees traded to the Indians before the non-waiver trade deadline in 2016, coolly retired Starlin Castro on a pop-up to escape.
But an inning later, he challenged Bird with a high fastball and Bird was ready for a pitch — and a moment — for which he’d long been waiting.